Which is healthier, sparkling water or soda?

Soda water has minerals deliberately added to it during manufacturing. Sparkling water is naturally sourced from a spring and carries whatever minerals were already dissolved in that water underground. That single difference in origin is what actually separates the taste, the ingredient list, and which one genuinely works better for different everyday uses.

All Three Terms, Side by Side

"Sparkling water" often gets used loosely as a catch-all term to mean several genuinely different things, which is exactly why the confusion exists in the first place. Here's what each one actually is, broken down by how it's made and what it contains.

Type Carbonation Source Minerals Taste
Soda Water / Club Soda Added artificially Added (sodium bicarbonate, etc.) Slightly salty
Sparkling Mineral Water Natural or added Naturally occurring, from source Varies by spring
Seltzer Added artificially None Clean, neutral

The practical upshot: soda water and seltzer both start from ordinary filtered tap water and get their fizz added mechanically, but soda water then has minerals deliberately mixed back in afterward, specifically to round out the flavour and offset the slight tang carbonation creates on its own. Sparkling mineral water skips that step entirely, because whatever minerals it carries were already dissolved into the water underground, long before it ever reached a bottle.

Which One Should You Actually Reach For

Mixing Cocktails

Soda water's slight minerality is specifically why it's the standard bar choice — it complements spirits rather than sitting completely flat and neutral against them, adding a small amount of structure to the drink.

Drinking With Food

Sparkling mineral water's natural character is genuinely built to be enjoyed on its own, and its subtle minerality can actually complement richer dishes the same way a wine pairing might.

Flavour Syrups or Fruit

Seltzer's completely neutral base means any added flavours come through cleanly and predictably, without any competing background mineral taste to fight against or mask.

There's an Actual Regulatory Threshold Involved

In the US, the FDA specifically requires water to contain at least 250 parts per million of dissolved solids — the minerals and trace elements naturally present from its source — before it can legally be labelled "mineral water" on the packaging. This is a genuine, measurable regulatory standard rather than just a loose marketing description, which is part of why the actual mineral content and resulting flavour can vary so noticeably from one bottled brand to another, even among products that all carry the same general "sparkling" or "mineral" labelling.

Per the FDA's own consumer guidance: minerals and trace elements in mineral water "must come from the source of the underground water. They cannot be added later."

Worth knowing in passing: "seltzer" actually takes its name from Selters, a German town once famous for naturally carbonated spring water — though modern seltzer, ironically, is almost always artificially carbonated rather than naturally sourced.

What to Actually Check on the Label

If you're standing in front of a shelf trying to work out which bottle is which, a few quick checks settle it faster than the front-of-pack branding alone. Look at the ingredients list first: if it simply says "carbonated water" with nothing else listed, you're almost certainly holding seltzer. If sodium bicarbonate, potassium sulfate, or similar minerals appear in that list, it's soda water or club soda. If the label instead names a specific spring, region, or source, and lists a defined mineral content rather than added ingredients, that's genuine sparkling mineral water, and the exact mineral profile will typically vary from one brand to the next depending on where it was actually bottled.

Read the Full Guide

Are Juice and Soft Drinks the Same Thing? →

Related Reading

Is Tonic Water a Soft Drink? →

Shop Our Soft Drinks Range

Soda water, tonic, and mixers for whatever you're making.

Shop Soft Drinks

Frequently Asked Questions

Is club soda the same thing as soda water?
Yes, these two terms are generally used interchangeably across most brands and regions — both refer to artificially carbonated water with minerals like sodium bicarbonate or potassium sulfate deliberately added during the production process, rather than describing two genuinely separate products.
Can seltzer be used as a substitute for sparkling mineral water?
For carbonation alone, yes, it works perfectly well, but seltzer's complete lack of minerals means it won't genuinely replicate the specific, nuanced flavour character that a particular sparkling mineral water gets from its individual source spring.
Does soda water contain any calories or sugar?
No, plain unflavoured soda water is genuinely calorie-free and sugar-free, with its added minerals contributing only to flavour rather than any meaningful nutritional content or caloric value whatsoever.
Why does sparkling water sometimes taste slightly salty?
This usually points directly to naturally occurring sodium already present in the source spring itself, with the exact level varying considerably depending on which specific spring or geographic region the water was originally bottled from.
Is tonic water part of this same comparison?
Not quite — tonic water is carbonated water with added quinine and a sweetener mixed in, giving it a distinctly bitter-sweet flavour profile that clearly sets it apart from the plainer soda, sparkling, and seltzer waters covered throughout this guide.

 

Tags:
Back to blog